Thursday, July 24, 2014

DAP: Fallacies and the devil’s bargain

IT IS IN THE NATURE of small men to be petty. And to have the inability to admit mistakes. This whole issue of the Disbursement Acceleration Program (DAP) should have been excised from public consciousness after the Supreme Court made its ruling. After all, there are bigger, more urgent problems to address. But the government’s insistence that it is right and may incorrigibly do something similar sticks out like a bad sore one feels compelled to pay attention to.

The consensus is that the Supreme Court was right to state that the DAP-related acts or measures were illegal. The counterpoint from government apologists, however, is that the illegality was more technical than real, something only lawyers obsess about. Of the morality of the DAP, such is unquestionably right as the government was in “good faith.”

But sadly they mislead. From ad hominem (the Supreme Court is obstructionist), self-righteous (we acted in good faith and hence we are right) and strawmen argumentation (lawyers insist only they can comment on DAP), to tu quoque fallacies (the Court can’t rule on the DAP as it did similar acts as well), all miss the point that the law is there to be followed not merely when things are going well but necessarily so when situations are dire.

And this is precisely one of the underlying principles of our Constitution. That ours is not a government of passions or self-righteous ideologues but of laws. As James Madison wrote in Federalist No. 51: “If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.”

This is what the Wall Street Journal was saying when it commented on the DAP: Mr. Aquino “created a bad precedent.” Unfortunately, “taking an unconstitutional shortcut only dilutes accountability, relieves voters and congressmen from the consequences of their choices, and sets the stage for a more corrupt president in 2016 or beyond to channel spending for his own benefit.”

And frankly, the government itself was engaging in another fallacy: that of “either/or.” Either we did the DAP or social justice programs would have collapsed. That is a false dichotomy. As other commentators have pointed out, some of the programs for which the DAP was employed were actually truly needed. But the need for them had been identified long ago. Why then was it not vigorously insisted to be included in previous budgets? This administration had at least starting 2011 to do that.

The administration’s complaint is that our system is slow. That’s no excuse. Our system was precisely designed to be slow. To force each branch of government to confer with others, to ponder deeply, to force officials to move without haste, to plan far ahead.

The fact is, the government has fallen into the trap that many other governments before succumbed to: the belief of the righteousness of its cause and that it could solve everything only if it had the power to do so. Thus, like many other past governments, it comes before the people offering a deal: give us more power and we will achieve more. Give us more power and we will make your life better. We will get rid of corruption. We will be free of inequality. The offer will be about anything and everything. But such is a devil’s bargain.

Because we know this: “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” We don’t even need refer to Lord Acton for this. Our history has that politician who promised all, including a nation great again -- only if he had more power.

Going back to the argument that the DAP issue is not only for lawyers: of course it isn’t. Matters of national concern involve every citizen’s duty and participation.

Ultimately (and many seem to not understand this), our political system is built on the idea that our country’s destiny lies not with the government but with the people. That’s why our government is one of merely limited powers. As Madison put’s it: government is merely an “auxiliary precaution,” there to assist the people to be able to do things for themselves.

Ours is a government of public servants, with limited functions delegated to them by the people. And the first thing they need to do to be good servants is to humbly set the good example of following the law.

Jemy Gatdula specializes in international economic law (WTO and ASEAN), and teaches international law and legal philosophy at the UA&P School of Law and Governance.

jemygatdula@yahoo.com

www.jemygatdula.blogspot.com


Mr Gatdula is also on Facebook and Twitter


source:  Businessworld

The problem with the high court

THE PROBLEM with President Noynoy Aquino and Budget Secretary Butch Abad is they are not mutant X-Men. They have no psychic powers. They cannot foretell what the Supreme Court will do. And they cannot exercise mind control over the members of the Supreme Court.

The problem is they are unlike Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo whose powers were so strong she could exercise mind control over Supreme Court justices even after she left Malacañang. Remember the Truth Commission and the Temporary Restraining Order on Gloria Arroyo’s hold departure order?

If the President and Abad had psychic powers, the Supreme Court would have upheld the constitutionality of the Disbursement Acceleration Program (DAP), and we would not have a crisis involving the Executive and the Supreme Court. We would have moved forward as a team.

Aquino and Abad are mere mortals who, in the case of the DAP, want to stimulate the economy through efficient and responsive public spending. The first thing they did upon assuming power was to review government spending, which in the previous administration was characterized by waste. The review slowed government spending and resulted in lower GDP (gross domestic product) growth rate. But the meticulous review of spending, especially in infrastructure, was necessary. Leaks had to be plugged before the ship of State could set sail again. Once the major leaks were plugged, the President and Abad hoisted the sails and went full speed ahead. The DAP was the hoist.

The DAP, in its essence the use of savings from other budget items to augment resources for underfunded important programs, is nothing new. It was a mechanism that was used by all previous previous administration since Cory Aquino’s, albeit under different names.

Like everyone not gifted with psychic powers, the President and Abad relied on well-established precedents, the Constitution, and the Administrative Code of 1987, specifically Book 6, Chapter 5, sections 38, 39, 49 (9) and (10). The Supreme Court on the other hand chose to ignore those well-established precedents and sections of the Administrative Code, focusing instead on those provisions in the Constitution that clashed with the provisions of the same Constitution the President and Abad stood by.

Such is the game of lawyers. Each side can present legal arguments to bolster its case. However, only the Supreme Court can end the debate and decide which argument is valid.

Having a final arbiter is good because lawyers will debate until someone puts a stop to it. But the final arbiter must always be one whose impartiality is above suspicion. The rule of law, too, is founded on predictability and stability. And the rule of law eschews judicial overreach.

To repeat, each side in the DAP debate has legal and constitutional arguments. The administration’s position is not a lonely one. The erudite lawyer Rene Saguisag, a gadfly for any administration, emphasizes the point that the President’s case on the DAP is “legally tenable and defensible.”

Even though the Supreme Court used legal arguments to strike down the essence of the DAP, the effect is devastating.

The Supreme Court ruling reinforces the belief that it creates instability and unpredictability of rules. The DAP, or its various forms in previous administrations, is normal practice. It is a fiscal tool for budget management and even for macroeconomic management. But the Supreme Court ruling, especially its presumption of the absence of good faith on the part of the Executive, will make the bureaucracy timid and in the immediate term will paralyze the implementation of projects.

The signal for bureaucrats or civil servants is that any innovative reform that invites controversy is dangerous. Bold reformist decisions and actions run the risk of being subjected to the intrusive interference of the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court’s overreach is best illustrated by its insistence on its definition of savings (which is what is saved by near end of the year). This is vastly different from how a businessman, an economist, a student or a housewife determines savings.

The DAP ruling should be seen in the broader context in which the contemporary Supreme Court has created policy and institutional instability or unpredictability. To name a few:

• In March 2011, the Supreme Court reversed its own ruling on the cityhood law, specifically turning upside down an earlier decision on the illegality of converting municipality into cities.

• In October 2011, the Supreme Court, invoking technicality, took back its “final” resolution, which ordered the reinstatement of 1,400 flight attendants of the Philippine Airlines.

The president of the Flight Attendants and Stewards Association of the Philippines, Bob Anduiza, said: “Imagine, by a mere letter from Attorney Mendoza, the Supreme Court recalled three previous decisions!” (Estelito Mendoza is the lawyer of Philippine Airlines.)

• In November 2013, the Supreme Court declared the Priority Development Assistance Fund (PDAF) or the pork barrel system unconstitutional even though it ruled three times before that the PDAF or its earlier version, the Countrywide Development Fund, was constitutional.

In fact, in the first decision, the Supreme Court said that the pork barrel system was “imaginative and innovative.”

Apart from the reversals of decisions, opaque actions tarnish the integrity of the contemporary Supreme Court.

During the impeachment of Chief Justice Renato Corona, then Associate Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno agreed to testify before the impeachment court on how it reached its decision on the case of the Philippine Airlines Employees Association case. The Court gagged her.

Another instance of opaqueness is the ongoing investigation on the “Madame Arlene” case, which is about the allegation that this woman acts as a fixer with the Court. The investigation started months ago, and we haven’t heard a pip about it.

And now the Court is divided as to whether to suspend or dismiss a Sandigan justice who Associate Justice Angelina Sandoval-Gutierrez found guilty of accepting a bribe to acquit Janel Lim Napoles in a malversation case connected to the purchase of Kevlar helmets. Who voted for dismissal and who voted for suspension? Only the Court knows.

In light of all these, it is perfectly understandable that we question the Court’s ruling on the DAP. Enough is enough.

And so, if the problem with the President and Abad is they are not X-Men, the problem with the Supreme Court is it has become the team of Magneto -- unrestrained, disruptive and divisive mutants.n

Manuel Buencamino and Filomeno Sta. Ana III are fellows of Action for Economic Reforms.

www.aer.ph

Sunday, June 29, 2014

SC rules miners foreign-owned

THE SUPREME COURT (SC) has barred three mining firms from operating in the Philippines for failing to comply with the ownership requirements set by the Constitution.

The high court, in a 31-page decision, found that Narra Nickel Mining and Development Corp., Tesoro Mining and Development, Inc., and McArthur Mining, Inc. are effectively controlled by MBMI Resources, Inc. a Canadian firm.

“We of this Court note that a grave violation of the Constitution… is being committed by a foreign corporation right under our country’s nose through a myriad of corporate layering under different, allegedly, Filipino corporations,” Associate Justice Presbitero J. Velasco wrote.

The case originated from Redmont Consolidated Mines Corp.’s decision to seek exertion concessions in Palawan province, only to find that the three companies had Mineral Production Sharing Agreement (MPSA) applications with the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), which were later granted.

A year later, Redmont questioned the mining company’s ownership before DENR’s panel of arbitrators and sought the revocation of their MPSAs. The arbitrators, in a December 2007 ruling, revoked the MPSAs granted to the three firms for “being foreign corporations.”

The Mines and Adjudication Board (MAB), however, reversed the arbitrators, which led Redmont to seek a review of the MAB decision before the Court of Appeals (CA).

The CA granted Redmont’s plea, ruling the MBMI “owned majority of the common stocks of the three firms as well as at least 60% equity interest of other majority shareholders of petitioners through joint venture agreements.”

The appellate court decision led the mining companies to seek relief before the Supreme Court.

In its ruling, the Supreme Court said: “Corporate layering is admittedly allowed by the FIA (Foreign Investments Act); but if it is used to circumvent the Constitution and pertinent laws, then it becomes illegal.”

Applying the “grandfather rule,” the Supreme Court ruled MBMI owns 60% or more of their equity interests.

“In effect, whether looking at the capital structure or the underlying relationships between and among corporations, petitioners are not Filipino nationals and must be considered foreign since 60% or more of their capital stock or equity interest are owned by MBMI,” the Supreme Court said.

In determining Filipino ownership, the stricter “grandfather rule” examines the nationality of stockholders. The more lenient “control test” on the other hand declares a corporation of Philippine nationality if its capital is at least 60% owned by Filipinos.

“Obviously, the instant case presents a situation which exhibits a scheme employed by stockholders to circumvent the law, creating a cloud of doubt in the Court’s mind. To determine, therefore, the actual participation, direct or indirect of MBMI, the grandfather rule must be used,” the high court said.

The MPSA, under the Mining Act of 1995, allows 60% foreign ownership while a financial or technical assistance agreement (FTAA) allows for 100% foreign ownership.

The Office of the President, in a 2010 decision, likewise canceled MBMI’s FTAA for violating the Constitution. -- Mikhail Franz E. Flores


source: Businessworld

Saturday, May 3, 2014

Edca: Aquino insisted on consent provision

The new defense agreement between the Philippines and the United States took a long time to complete because President Aquino insisted on Philippine approval of all US military activities and the hardware that the Americans would bring into the country.

It was the insistence by the Philippine panel, taking orders from the President, to include the Mutual Defense Board (MDB) and the Security Engagement Board (SEB) as the approving bodies that caused a deadlock in the negotiations last year, a ranking government official told the Inquirer last week.

The source said the agreement was the only defense accord the United States had with an ally that carries a consent provision.

“With respect to storage, with respect to the types of matériel, we needed to know what [the Americans] would bring in. We would know what these are, then approve it through the MDB and the SEB,” the official said.

The two boards will also assess beforehand the construction of US infrastructure in Philippine military camps, the storage of US military hardware, called “prepositioning,” and “other related activities.”

The official, who preferred anonymity for lack of authority to talk to journalists, is familiar with the negotiations that took eight months.

“They reached a stalemate on the consenting mechanism because generally they (Americans) wanted to have as much leeway as possible. But [the Philippine side] insisted that any infrastructure should be for the betterment of the AFP (Armed Forces of the Philippines), [it should be] in line with our priorities,” the official said.

“That’s what dragged the talks out,” the official added.

Military cooperation
The Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement (Edca) is a framework agreement designed to further military cooperation between the Philippines and the United States.

It gives the US forces temporary access to selected Philippine military camps and allow them to preposition fighter jets and ships.

The agreement does not specify how many additional US troops will be deployed “on temporary and rotational basis,” but officials from both sides will determine the number depending on the scale of joint military activities to be held in Philippine camps.

The agreement was signed on April 28, hours before the arrival of US President Barack Obama in Manila for an overnight visit on the last leg of a tour of the Asia-Pacific region that also took in Japan, South Korea and Malaysia.

While both parties highlight the security accord’s importance to human assistance and disaster response, among other purposes, the agreement is widely viewed as a deterrent to China’s increasing aggressiveness in claiming territories in the South China Sea, including islands, islets and shoals in the West Philippine Sea, the waters within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone.

The negotiations ran into an impasse in November, after five rounds of discussions between the Philippine and American negotiators.

Defense Secretary Voltaire Gazmin told reporters that there were differences involving Philippine control and access to temporary US facilities that would be set up in Philippine military bases.


Two boards
The MDB, created under the Mutual Defense Treaty, and the SEB, formed under the Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA), are effective, the source said.

On its website, the VFA Commission defines the MDB, established in 1958, as a “continuing intergovernment machinery for direct liaison and consultation between appropriate Philippine and US authorities on military matters of mutual concern.”

The SEB, on the other hand, was created through the 2006 Romulo-Kenney Exchange of notes to complement the MDB.

The SEB provides “a framework and mechanism for direct and continuing liaison and consultation on nontraditional security concerns, such as but not limited to terrorism, transnational crimes, maritime security and safety, and natural and man-made disasters, between the appropriate Philippine and US authorities.”

Officials from the AFP and the US Pacific Command hold MDB-SEB meetings every year.

The official said the two boards would deal with the operational details that the public, the media and the agreement’s critics wanted to know, including the number of US troops that would be deployed to the Philippines.

Edca defended
In a separate interview, Ambassador to Malaysia J. Eduardo Malaya, a member of the Philippine negotiating panel, defended the agreement, saying “it was not a sellout.”

“We worked very hard to ensure that our interests are protected,” Malaya said.

For one, the United States wanted to have a longer time frame for the agreement, “understandably for their ROI (return of investment), but the Philippines insisted on a 10-year duration because it was more manageable and more acceptable to the public,” Malaya said.

The United States also gave in to the Philippines’ insistence that all infrastructure that would be built in Philippine military camps would eventually be turned over to the AFP, he said.

Malaya said the Philippines also insisted on “robust environmental provisions” as well as use of Philippine suppliers and services for US procurement requirements.

Environmental provision
Malaya reiterated that the agreement would not lead to the establishment of permanent US bases in the Philippines.

He said the US forces would not have exclusive use of Philippine camps and Philippine laws would prevail over the areas that the Americans would use.

The Americans will have exclusive use of their military hardware “understandably because they own them,” he said.

source:  Philippine Daily Inquirer

‘No need for telecom franchise, tax exemption for US forces’

MANILA, Philippines - There is no need for Congress to grant a franchise to US forces to operate a telecommunications system and exemption from paying local taxes under the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement (EDCA), legal experts in the House of Representatives said yesterday.
Deputy Speaker and Isabela Rep. Giorgidi Aggabao and Marikina City Rep. Romero Quimbo were responding to criticisms that the move to allow visiting US forces to operate their own telecommunication system and exempt them from paying taxes usurped the power of Congress to grant telecommunication franchises and tax exemptions.

“My opinion is if the grant of telecommunication rights to the US forces and their exemption from any taxes are among the stipulations in EDCA, I would think that stipulation becomes part of the supreme law of the land binding upon the legislature and the judiciary, and the assent of Congress is no longer required,” Aggabao said.

He cited statements from Malacañang that the EDCA is neither a new treaty nor an executive agreement, but is part of the Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA) between the Philippines and the US.
“I would add that the VFA is not only a law. It is a contract. Consequently, all its provisions, clear and definite, are binding to the entire branches of the contracting governments,” he said.

Quimbo said the country’s tax code provides a clear exemption of governmental functions of other nationals validly visiting the Philippines.

“If the grant of exemptions under EDCA is similar to what I have mentioned, then it is not outside of the authority of the executive branch. They are not giving a grant but effectively carrying out an edict which Congress has delegated to the executive,” he said.

Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Colmenares earlier scored the government for granting the US a franchise to operate a telecommunication system and all the radio band spectrums it requires.

Colmenares noted the granting of tax exemption for the US for its troops and contractors of water, electricity and other public utilities.

“While ordinary Filipinos pay value-added taxes and other fees for the use of electricity and other public utilities, we are subsidizing the taxes of the Americans,” Colmenares said.

“While the Bureau of Internal Revenue goes after Filipino taxpayers, Malacañang has given tax exemptions to the US. The grant of franchise and tax exemption is not within the power of the executive but is a power of Congress,” he said.

source:  Philippine Star



Friday, May 2, 2014

EDCA -- negotiated surrender of sovereignty

NOW we know why the "negotiations" for what would emerge as the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement (EDCA) were conducted under a cloak of secrecy. Not a single byte of the draft was made available to other government functionaries, not even the treaty-making arm of the Philippine state, the Senate, much less to the media and the general public.

In fact, to everyone’s consternation, no copies of the EDCA were released even after it was signed by Philippine Defense Secretary Gazmin and United States Ambassador Goldberg hours before the arrival of US President Obama for his swing-by visit to Manila. For surely, had the drafts and the final text of the EDCA been made public earlier, these would have raised the nationalist hackles of Filipinos, activist and non-activist alike, slowed down if not totally aborted the talks, and soured even further what the Aquino administration was trying mightily to project as a feel-good, arms-clasped coming together of two long-time friends and allies. The Aquino government only posted the EDCA on its official web site after Mr. Obama had left the country.

Despite its deceitful language, it is obvious that the "agreement" does not only allow the US to impinge on Philippine national sovereignty and territorial integrity by gaining access to so-called "Agreed Locations" purportedly in exchange for enhancing the Philippines’ external defense capabilities as well as boosting its capacity to respond to disasters.

Apart from a general statement in Article I, Purpose and Scope, "This Agreement deepens defense cooperation between the Parties... improving interoperability of the Parties’ forces, and for the AFP, addressing short-term capabilities gaps, promoting long-term modernization and helping maintain and develop additional maritime security, maritime domain awareness, and humanitarian assistance and disaster relief capabilities..." there is no other provision categorically stating how this objective shall be achieved. There is no clear, reciprocal provision stating just exactly how the Philippines will supposedly benefit from the EDCA.

On the contrary, Article III, Agreed Locations, says "Given the mutuality of benefits, the Parties agree that the Philippines shall make Agreed Locations available to the US forces without rental (boldface is ours) or similar costs." We recall that one of the main objections to the retention of US bases in sprawling areas of Central Luzon was the US refusal to pay a user’s fee while the country definitely shouldered huge lost opportunity costs by hosting the US bases.

And while in Article IV, Equipment, Supplies and Materiel, "The Philippines authorizes the US forces to preposition and store defense equipment, supplies and materiel ...at Agreed Locations," Section 3 states that "(t)he prepositioned materiel of US forces shall be for the exclusive use of US forces (boldface ours) ..."

And in Article VII, Utilities and Communications, "The Philippines hereby grants to US forces and US contractors the use of water, electricity, and other public utilities on terms and conditions, including rents or charges, no less favorable than those available to the AFP of the Government of the Philippines in like circumstances, less charges for taxes and similar fees, which shall be for the account of the Philippine government (boldface ours)."

Thus from these few provisions alone, the EDCA is grossly lopsided. But over and above this, a close reading of the EDCA reveals that it is indeed a sell-out, nothing less than the surrender of our national sovereignty to our former colonizer, the US of A.

The EDCA allows a much bigger, in fact unlimited, number of US troops to be stationed, together with their unlimited number of prepositioned war vessels and armaments; in unspecified locations, possibly anywhere in the country to be provided by the Philippine government; to undertake a host of activities amounting to using the country as a launching pad for US military adventures; and in a veritable open-ended duration of stay.

Article I on Purpose and Scope, which is supposed to define and delimit the scope of allowed activities, ends with a deliberately vague and catch-all phrase "...and such other activities that may be agreed upon by the Parties." This opens up the scope of activities that "the US may take in the territory of the Philippines in relation to the access to and use of Agreed Locations" to any other conceivable activity that is not explicitly stipulated in the Agreement.

One might argue that the Agreement categorically states that these activities are "within" and in relation to its "access to and use of Agreed Locations" which, in Art. II Definitions, "may be listed in an annex appended to this agreement." However, the listing is not intended to define the territorial limits of these activities, since the provision again ends with the phrase, "...and may be further described in implementing arrangements."

The EDCA is thus far worse than the return of the former US bases and facilities in the country that were booted out by the Philippine Senate’s rejection of the bases agreement in 1991. Then, the US troops and war materiel were confined in well-defined or specific areas, albeit with extraterritorial rights, and their sea and air war machines could only dock in or land on these military bases. Whereas now, while the EDCA states that US facilities shall only be set up in "Agreed Locations" and again, purportedly, without exclusivity, this proviso is negated by the caveat allowing "Agreed Locations" anywhere both Parties agree on.

A specific provision in Art III, section 2 states, "When requested the Designated Authority of the Philippines shall assist in facilitating transit or temporary access by US forces to public land and facilities (including roads, ports and airfields) including those owned or controlled by local governments, and to other land and facilities..." Ergo contrary to the Philippine and US governments’ propaganda that only AFP facilities will host the US troops and war material or will be the site of their activities, the EDCA opens the way for American boots to go anywhere they need or wish to go in Philippine territory including "roads, ports and airfields" used entirely for civilian purposes.

As to the duration of the EDCA, Article XII, Section 4 states, "This agreement shall have an initial term of 10 years, and thereafter it shall continue in force automatically (boldface ours) unless terminated by either Party..." This is a far cry from what the Aquino government wants to make us believe that the EDCA has a definite duration of 10 years the way the RP-US bases agreement had a definite termination in 1991.

A most objectionable and potentially explosive issue, being a case where the Executive branch has clearly overstepped its bounds, is the provision in Art XI, Resolution of Disputes. Any dispute "arising under this Agreement" must be resolved "...exclusively through consultations between the Parties.... (and) shall not be referred to any national or international court, tribunal, or other similar body, or to any third party for settlement, unless otherwise agreed by the Parties."

This is supposed to mean that neither the Senate nor Supreme Court can question or revise the Agreement. This is a blatantly unconstitutional provision, violating the principle and letter of checks and balances and division of powers in government. Clearly, the Executive has encroached on the Legislative and Judicial branches’ powers and prerogatives in barring the subjection of the Agreement to legislative or judicial review.

In any case, it is now also clear why the EDCA was "negotiated" in addition to the Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA) and Mutual Logistics Support Agreement (MLSA) which had already in principle and practice opened up Philippine territory and resources to US military forces and activities. The EDCA was crafted to further legalize and justify more obtrusive increased US presence and activities which the vague VFA and MLSA provisions could not as easily or evidently cover up.


source:  Businessworld / Streetwise  - Carol Pagaduan-Araullo

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

China rejects PH argument on territorial row

MANILA, Philippines—China on Monday said it would not accept and participate in the written argument submitted by the Philippines to the United Nations (UN) International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (Itlos) .

“China does not accept the international arbitration initiated by the Philippine side. Disputes such as these have already been excluded from arbitration procedures through a declaration made by China in 2006 pursuant to the United Nations Convention on the Laws Of the Sea (Unclos),” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei told Chinese reporters in a press briefing.

Hong said China urges the Philippines to adhere to using bilateral talks to resolve the maritime dispute.
Hong added that the direct cause of the dispute was the Philippines’ illegal occupation of some Chinese islets adding that China held a clear and consistent stance on its claims over the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea).

According to Hong, China has “indisputable sovereignty over the Ayungin Shoal and its adjacent waters.”

Foreign Affairs spokesman Charles Jose , meanwhile, said the Philippine government maintains its position to resolve the maritime dispute in a peaceful and diplomatic manner.

“We have been advocating peaceful settlement of the dispute without resorting to force or threat of force,” Jose said in an interview over Inquirer Radio 990AM.

Jose said the written argument or memorial submitted by the Philippines to the arbitration committee of the United Nation is the “most peacful, durable and lasting solution” to the maritime dispute.

He said the UN arbitral tribunal would continue the hearing of the  written memorial submitted by the Philippines even without China’s  participation and approval.

On Sunday,  the Philippines submitted a 4,000-page written pleading of the Philippines before an international tribunal against China’s expansive claims over the West Philippine Sea.

Chinese coast guard  vessels on Saturday blocked a civilian Philippine ship off the Ayungin Shoal in the Spratly Islands .

The civilian ship brought supplies to Philippine soldiers stationed at the BRP Sierra Madre that has been grounded at the Ayungin Shoal, an area within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone, but which China claims as its own.

source:  Philippine Daily Inquirer